Kurt Vonnegut was a literary legend who created his own story structures. His story shapes are all about showing how characters go through ups and downs, like starting off in a bad place and working their way out. It’s less about following strict rules and more about creating fun, quirky tales.
Let’s break down Vonnegut’s story shapes and see how he maps out his plots — there are lots of surprises and turns ahead!
What you’ll learn in this article:
- Kurt Vonnegut’s unique story shapes.
- How emotional highs and lows make stories compelling.
- Classic story structures like “Man in Hole” and “Cinderella.”
- How to use Vonnegut’s shapes to create engaging narratives.
Origin of Vonnegut’s Story Shapes
Like every other student, Kurt Vonnegut submitted his thesis paper on how society’s stories follow specific shapes of stories.
But lady luck didn’t knock on his door — his thesis was rejected by the University of Chicago’s anthropology department. Vonnegut said,
“It was rejected because it was so simple and looked like too much fun.”
Talk about bad fortune!
But guess what? The idea persisted, and Kurt Vonnegut’s failed thesis is now hailed as one of the most fun and engaging approaches to story structure ever defined. In his autobiography, Palm Sunday, Vonnegut claimed that his “prettiest contribution” to the culture is his theory on the shapes of stories.
🌍 The single largest and best fantasy/mythology shared book universe in existence (that I know of).
Here’s what you get when you join:
🌟 All Argovale books for FREE! That’s right, get access to Argovale books that’s worth $499 in value.
✅ Weekly calls and guided sessions with the author.
✅ Get feedback and inspiration from a creative, like-minded community
✅ Access to the best fantasy readers group in the world.
Kurt Vonnegut’s Story Shapes
Kurt Vonnegut, Slaughterhouse-Five author, had a theory: stories have shapes, and those shapes are just as revealing as a culture’s greatest artifacts. In his words,
“There’s no reason why the simple shapes of stories can’t be fed into computers. They are beautiful shapes.”
To prove his point, he mapped every story onto a graph in two axes. The vertical axis—what he called the GI-Axis—tracked the protagonist’s fortune, from sheer misery to pure bliss.
The horizontal BE-Axis? That was the journey, from the beginning to the end of the tale.
If you like this article, you might enjoy the Great Courses Plus, which is my favorite way to learn more about mythology and ancient history.
If you’re interested, readers of StorytellingDB get a special 25% off for any of the plans if you use this link. Full disclosure, this is an affiliate link, but it costs you nothing extra and every bit goes to my children’s diaper fund.
The 8 Shapes of Stories
Alright, let’s dive in and see how each of these eight simple shapes takes form on Vonnegut’s legendary diagram. Trust me, it’s a fun read.
1. Man in Hole
The story starts with the protagonist in a neutral spot — nothing exciting, nothing disastrous. Then, life throws them into a hole — bad luck, challenges, the whole mess.
Just when it looks like they’re stuck for good, they pull themselves together, fight their way out, and come out stronger, smarter, and in a way better place than before.
Classic underdog comeback — never gets old. As Vonnegut’s said:
“Somebody gets into trouble. Gets out of it again. People love that story. They never get sick of it.”
He also said:
“Be a sadist. No matter how sweet and innocent your leading characters, make awful things happen to them — so the reader may see what they’re made of.”
The simplest example of the Man in the Hole structure? The Lion King — Simba’s got it all until Uncle Scar tricks him into thinking he caused his father’s death.
Guilt-ridden, he runs away (hello, “hole” structure), but fate drags him back. Instead of hiding, he fights, wins, and reclaims the throne. Classic fall, rise, and triumph.
2. Boy Meets Girl
In Boy Meets Girl, the protagonist finds something — or someone — truly special, and they fall head over heels. But, of course, love isn’t a straight road. Along the way, they hit roadblocks, face heartbreak, and everything seems to fall apart.
Just when it looks like all hope is lost, they dig deep, let their passion take the wheel, and fight to get that love back. And in the end? It’s all happily ever after — because, let’s be honest, we wouldn’t have it any other way.
Vonnegut explains it so beautifully:
“Starts on an average day, average person, not expecting anything to happen. A day like any other. Then—bam!—finds something wonderful. Just loves it. Then—oh, goddammit—loses it. But then… gets it back again. People like that.”
Let’s take an example of the movie Proposal. Margaret, a no-nonsense book editor, is about to be deported—so she forces her assistant, Andrew, into a fake engagement. He’s not thrilled, but hey, promotion’s on the table.
Off to Alaska they go, where Margaret’s icy heart starts to thaw (thanks to quirky family chaos and an unhinged grandma). But then—the truth’s out, hearts shatter, and she runs back to New York.
Andrew? Not on his watch. He chases after her, confesses, and proposes for real. Fake love turns real—classic rom-com magic!
3. From Bad to Worse
This one’s a bit of a downer with a dash of hope. The protagonist starts off in a rough spot—maybe they’re struggling, unlucky, or just barely getting by. Then, just when they think things can’t get worse, they do. Way worse.
Life of Pi is the ultimate bad-to-worse tale. Pi’s family struggles, so they move to Canada — then, shipwreck. Now he’s stranded at sea… with a tiger.
Survival’s a nightmare — hunger, storms, and not becoming tiger lunch. He makes it out, but his family’s gone, and we’re left questioning if any of it was real. Not exactly a fairytale ending, but there’s a hint of hope.
4. Which Way is Up?
This one’s a bit tricky—not for us, but for the poor protagonist. They start off below the midpoint (let’s call that a decent spot), but life throws them into a rollercoaster of seemingly random ups and downs.
It’s a whole zigzag ride, really. But don’t worry, just when it seems like chaos is all they’ll ever know, they finally catch a break and land on some good fortune in the end.
Let’s talk Forrest Gump. The guy starts off in a rough spot — leg braces, low IQ, everyone underestimates him. But then, life throws him into a rollercoaster of seemingly random ups and downs.
He becomes a football star (nice), gets shipped off to Vietnam (not so nice), starts a shrimp business (cool), loses his best friend (ouch), accidentally invests in Apple and gets filthy rich (talk about luck).
5. Cinderella
Your classic rags-to-riches arc — starting at rock bottom, hitting a lucky break, soaring high… then disaster strikes. But don’t worry, they rally back even stronger, ending up happier, richer, and way better off.
Vonnegut called this one a fan-favorite — because let’s be real, who doesn’t love a good comeback story?
Oh, you know exactly who’s he talking about. Cinderella (duh)
I’m gonna let Vonnegut do the talking on this one:
“Now, surprisingly enough, this one starts way down here. Lower than anything else. Worse than that—it’s a little girl.
What’s happened? Her mother has died. Her father has remarried a vile-tempered, ugly woman with two nasty daughters. Big daughters. You’ve heard it.
Anyway, there’s a party at the palace that night. She can’t go. She had to help everybody else get ready. She has to stay home.
Now, does she sink lower? No. She’s a tough little thing. And she’s already had the worst fate can throw at her—the loss of her mother. She can’t go lower than that.
Okay, so the fairy godmother comes! Gives her shoes, gives her stockings, gives her mascara—
Gives her a way to get to the party. She goes, dances with the prince, has a swell time. Boring, boring, boring, boring, boring—
Now, there’s a slight incline to that line because, well, it takes maybe twenty, thirty seconds for a grandfather clock to strike twelve. Does she end up at the same level? Of course not! She’ll remember that dance for the rest of her life.
Then she drifts along until the prince comes with the shoe. And then—shoe fits—she achieves off-scale happiness!”
6. Good News, Bad News
Just because this story has no curves doesn’t mean it’s a failure — Shakespeare used it too! It reflects life’s unpredictability, where setbacks might lead to something better.
An example of this arc is No Country for Old Men (2007). The story unfolds without a clear rise or fall — characters make choices, events happen, but there’s no traditional resolution or moral clarity. Just like life, it moves forward unpredictably, leaving us questioning what was truly good or bad.
7. Creation Story
The world starts as a blank slate — chaotic, empty, or boring — until something (or someone) creates order and meaning.
In The Lego Movie – Emmet lives in a bland, rule-following world until he embraces creativity. By the end, he helps build a new world where imagination reigns. Everything is awesome… eventually.
8.Tragedy
Everything starts off great — love, success, promise — but thanks to bad decisions or fate, it all falls apart. No happy endings here.
Romeo and Juliet – They fall madly in love in 0.2 seconds, but their families’ feud (and a few tragic misunderstandings) lead to their untimely deaths. Moral of the story? Maybe text before faking your death.
Tips for Creating Compelling Stories
Want to craft stories that hook readers and don’t let go? Vonnegut’s story shapes are your secret weapon. Here’s how to use them effectively:
- Pick the Right Shape: Start by choosing a structure that fits your story’s core conflict. Man in a Hole for a comeback story, Boy Meets Girl for romance, or Which Way Is Up? for unpredictable chaos.
- Heighten the Highs, Deepen the Lows: The bigger the fall, the more satisfying the rise. Push your protagonist to rock bottom before letting them climb back up. Readers love an emotional rollercoaster.
- Keep the Momentum Going: Every scene should either push the story forward or raise the stakes. If it doesn’t, cut it. Vonnegut’s shapes are all about movement and transformation.
- Surprise Your Audience: Even within a familiar shape, throw in unexpected twists. Just because the path is mapped out doesn’t mean the journey has to be predictable.
- Make It Personal: The best stories aren’t just well-structured; they’re deeply felt. Infuse your narrative with real emotions, stakes, and consequences to make it resonate.
Final Thoughts
So, is Vonnegut’s theory actually useful when it comes to crafting compelling stories? I think it is. Kurt Vonnegut’s story shapes aren’t just amusing—they’re a masterclass in storytelling made simple. His diagrams strip away the fluff and reveal the raw, emotional arcs that keep readers hooked.
Whether it’s the classic “Man in Hole” comeback, the zigzag chaos of “Which Way Is Up?” or the bittersweet irony of “Good News, Bad News,” Vonnegut proves that great storytelling isn’t about rigid formulas — it’s about movement, transformation, and keeping your audience on their toes.
So next time you’re crafting a story, take a page from Vonnegut: map it out, embrace the curves, and above all — make it fun.
